CNN host Michael Smerconish raised eyebrows Saturday when he argued that it is time to confront “hard” questions about whether Islam is compatible with Western society. He pointed to repressive laws in many Muslim-majority countries that target gays, women and people who leave the faith.
Speaking on his weekend program, Smerconish said those questions have to be asked as the planet becomes an “increasingly Muslim world.”
The segment came days after a new Pew Research Center report projected that Muslims will outnumber Christians worldwide by 2035, which would make Islam the world’s largest religion within roughly a decade.
According to Pew, there are about 2 billion Muslims today, compared with an estimated 2.3 billion Christians. The gap is closing fast because Muslim women average 3.1 children while Christian women average 2.5. Between 2020 and 2070, natural population change is projected to add 1.6 billion Muslims and 792 million Christians.
“There’s also a hard question we shouldn’t dodge,” Smerconish told viewers. He then listed governments that enforce blasphemy laws, restrict women and persecute religious minorities.
Citing Pew data, the CNN host noted that 18 of the 20 countries in the Middle East and North Africa have blasphemy laws on the books, and 13 of them make leaving the faith a crime.
He added that seven countries prescribe death for same-sex relations, six of them under Islamic law. The seventh, he acknowledged, is Uganda, which is majority Christian.
Smerconish also said concerns that Muslims are pushing their religious beliefs onto European communities have led to “real” debates about integration on the continent. He argued those concerns are warranted given conditions in many Muslim-majority nations.
As Muslims make up a growing share of humanity, Smerconish said, the issue carries real consequences for religious freedom around the world.
Still, the CNN host urged Americans to keep their focus on foreign governments and their laws rather than on the Muslims living next door.
“Demography isn’t conquest,” he said.
Smerconish also hosts a SiriusXM radio program and has long presented himself as an independent voice. Even so, his candid framing is a notable departure in tone for CNN. In August, CNN anchor Omar Jimenez pressed Rep. Nancy Mace, R-S.C., during a tense live interview over her social media posts about Muslim Americans and Muslim elected officials.
Smerconish’s segment arrives as debates over immigration, assimilation and religious liberty continue to play out on both sides of the Atlantic. His bottom line was that the world’s changing religious makeup is a subject Americans can no longer afford to ignore, but one that should be argued on the basis of laws and governments rather than individual believers.
